UNION COLLEGE 2010 RUBE GOLDBERG MACHINE CONTEST
April 17, 2010
OFFICIAL JUDGING FORM FOR TEAM:                                                        

1. Effectiveness of the Machine
Points
a. Machine conformed to the stated requirements (1 to 5) ____
b. Machine worked on the first trial    [up to 6 points for PPBs caught] (1 to 10) ____
c. Machine worked on the second trial    [up to 6 points for PPBs caught] (1 to 10) ____
d. Five-minute rule violated  * (-1 to -5) ____
e. Human intervention required  ** (-2 each) ____
Judging Group ____ Initials ____     Subtotal 1  (25 points max)    ____

2. Complexity of the machine 

a. Machine's first 20 steps.  (Add 1 point for every 2 steps.)

(1 to 10) ____

b. Machine has more than 20 steps.

(Add 1/2 point for each step beyond 20.) (10 max) ____
c. Machine's forms of energy conversion.  
(List up to 10 here and give 1 point for the first 5 and 2 points for each additional form.)
    1.                                                            6.

    2.                                                            7.

    3.                                                            8.

    4.                                                            9.

    5.                                                            10. (1 to 15) ____
Judging Group ____ Initials ____     Subtotal 2  (35 points max)    ____

3. Creativity of the students 

a. Students demonstrated creative thought in their design (1 to 5) ____
b. Students produced a creative and effective theme (1 to 5) ____
c. Rube Goldberg spirit (i.e, a complex machine) demonstrated (1 to 5) ____
d. Machine is esthetically pleasing (1 to 5) ____
Judging Group ____ Initials ____     Subtotal 3  (20 points max)    ____

4. Student Presentation to the judges

a. Team demonstrated enthusiasm and team work (1 to 5) ____
b. Team explained the machine clearly and completely    [included volume calculation] (1 to 5) ____
c. Informative handouts available (1 to 5) ____
d. An accurate and descriptive poster was displayed (1 to 5) ____
Judging Group ____ Initials ____     Subtotal 4  (20 points max)    ____

Comments below:                                             TOTAL POINTS:  (100 points max)    _______



Judge's Signature: _______________________________

*   Each team is allowed five minutes to complete two runs (including reset time).  One point is deducted for each additional minute required to a maximum of 5 points.

**  If the same intervention is required on the second trial it does not result in additional point loss.

--- The Rube Goldberg Contest is a Trademark of Rube Goldberg Inc. ---